The Minnow Revolution in Patagonia

The Minnow Revolution in Patagonia

How the Collón Curá Changed Forever

A River That Changed Overnight

Every year, sometime between late February and the end of the fishing season, the
Collón Curá seems to become a different river. Almost overnight, floating lines give
way to sinking lines, streamer boxes replace dry-fly boxes, and guides begin watching
for the first schools of puyén, a small native minnow that suddenly becomes the trout’s
preferred prey.

Today, guides and anglers simply call it the minnow season. Most visiting anglers
assume it has always been part of the river’s rhythm.

It has not. During the 1980s and early 1990s, after more than a decade guiding anglers
on the Collón Curá, I thought I understood the river remarkably well. I knew its
seasonal rhythms, its hatches, its terrestrial fishing, and the places trout were most likely
to hold throughout the year. Like every guide who spends enough time on a river, I
believed I had learned most of its secrets.

I was wrong.

The Reservoir and the First Signs

In 1993, as the new Piedra del Águila Reservoir began filling, the entire river system
started changing before our eyes. As the water slowly backed upstream, dozens of miles of the middle Limay and lower Collón Curá valleys disappeared beneath the rising
reservoir. An outstanding trout fishery and one of northern Patagonia’s most beautiful
river landscapes were lost forever.

For those of us who knew that river, it was a painful transformation. Yet while one
chapter of the Collón Curá’s history was ending, another was quietly beginning. None
of us recognized it at the time.

That same year, while filming an episode of Fly Fishing the World with Robert Duvall
and producer John Barrett, I witnessed the first signs of the change.

We were fishing a stretch of the lower Collón Curá that no longer exists. The reservoir
was still rising, and before long that entire section would disappear beneath the water.

Everywhere we looked, trout were crashing into enormous schools of puyén. Brown and
rainbow trout charged through the baitfish with astonishing intensity, often driving them
against the banks before attacking in spectacular surface explosions.

Robert watched the commotion for a few moments, then turned toward me.

“What are those fish doing?” he asked.

“They’re chasing puyén minnows,” I replied. “And that is going to make them very
difficult to catch.”

We filmed the action, but I thought we were simply seeing an unusually large
concentration of baitfish. I had no idea we were watching the beginning of an entirely
new chapter in the history of the Collón Curá.

One memorable trout Robert landed that day came from beside a large riverside boulder
our guides later nicknamed Duvall’s Rock. Today, both the rock and that entire stretch
of river lie beneath the reservoir.

A Prediction That Took Time to Understand

The following season, I described what we had witnessed to Montana guide Jim Stibbs, who was then guiding for Patagonia Outfitters. Jim listened carefully, smiled, and said something I have never forgotten.

“You have no idea what this river is going to become, Jorge.”

“What do you mean?” I asked.

“One of these days you’re going to start seeing monsters come out of this river.”

At the time, I was not convinced. The trout were clearly taking advantage of an extraordinary new food source, but predicting that this would eventually produce exceptionally large brown trout seemed like quite a leap.

As it turned out, Jim understood the significance of what we had seen long before the rest of us did.

The Evidence Appears

Another fishing season passed. Then another. Gradually, the river began producing exactly the kind of trout Jim had predicted.

The first unmistakable evidence, at least for us, came during the fall of 1996.

Patagonia Outfitters guest David Fell was fishing with guide Robert Ramsay when, before they even reached the river, their truck became hopelessly stuck in the mud.

“You go ahead and fish,” Robert told him. “I’ll get the truck out.”

A short while later, Robert heard David shouting from the river. By the time he reached him, David was fighting an exceptionally large brown trout, later estimated at around fifteen pounds.

For all of us, it was an eye-opening fish. Jim’s prediction no longer seemed far-fetched.

Three years later, during the 1999 season, more evidence followed. Guest Jonathan Tate landed a magnificent 31-inch brown trout, one of the largest fish we had ever seen from the Collón Curá. That same season, Cathy Beck landed a beautifully colored fall brown—another sign that the river was producing larger, healthier trout than we had been accustomed to seeing.

Searching for the Pattern

By then, one question kept coming back to me: if these fish were now part of the river, why weren’t we catching more of them?

I discussed the question with Alejandro del Valle, Director of Fish and Wildlife for the Province of Neuquén. Alejandro believed the explanation was  traightforward: the largest brown trout probably spent most of the year feeding in the reservoir before entering the Collón Curá during the fall to spawn.

The idea made perfect sense, but I wanted to see the  evidence with my own eyes.

During the final week of the 2000 fishing season, I organized a four-day exploratory float trip with several Patagonia Outfitters guides, launching from  Estancia Quemquemtreu. Our objective was simple: to determine whether the remarkable fish caught during previous seasons had been isolated exceptions—or whether the river had profoundly changed.

None of us expected what happened next.

Early in the trip, guide Diego Gaiser landed an exceptionally large brown trout, estimated at around ten pounds. We celebrated the fish but quietly wondered whether it might simply be another fortunate catch.

It was not.

As the float continued downstream, more mature browns were hooked and landed. By then, it had become obvious that we were no longer looking at isolated fish. The Collón Curá itself had changed.

The largest trout of the trip was landed by guide Hernando Fernández Beschtedt and was  estimated at around fifteen pounds. By the time we reached the take-out, there was little doubt left: Jim Stibbs had recognized the future of the Collón Curá years before the rest of us.

The river had been telling us something. We simply had not yet learned how to read the signs.

Those memorable trout were not the story. They were evidence that something much bigger had taken place beneath the surface.

Putting the Pieces Together

More than thirty years later, the pieces finally fit together.

Puyén had always been part of the Collón Curá ecosystem. Long before the reservoir was created, these small native minnows inhabited the river system, but never in the extraordinary numbers we began seeing after 1993.

As the newly formed reservoir matured, it created conditions in which the puyén population expanded dramatically. During those first years—especially in late summer—enormous schools of puyén began moving upstream from the reservoir into the Collón Curá.

From our drift boats, we  watched clouds of minnows surround us and carpet the riverbanks. They were small, slender fish that moved together almost like tiny eels, steadily making their way upstream.

Brown and rainbow trout followed them, taking advantage of an abundant food source.

The feeding activity was unlike anything we had ever witnessed before.

The same phenomenon developed, although on a smaller scale, in the lower Caleufú River, which also flows into the same reservoir. That was another sign that we were witnessing a system-wide ecological change, not something unique to one stretch of river.

At the time, our best explanation was that the puyén were moving upstream to spawn.

We never confirmed that biologically, but after watching the same migration repeat year after year in late summer, we could think of no other explanation that fit what we were seeing.

How the Migration Changed the Fishing

For guides, those ecological changes gradually transformed the way we approached the river. Streamers were not new on the Collón Curá. Long before the minnow season developed, we regularly fished Woolly Buggers, Matukas, and other small streamers—especially during spring, whenever trout showed little surface activity, or when introducing beginners to fly fishing. Some anglers also preferred streamers because they often produced higher catch rates than dry flies.

As summer progressed, however, the Collón Curá traditionally became a dry-fly and terrestrial fishery. Grasshopper patterns, Stimulators, attractors, Parachute Hoppers, beetles, and other surface flies became the standard approach as warm weather settled in.

The arrival of the puyén migration changed all of that.

During those first years, trout fed with an intensity that could only be described as a frenzy. Dry flies, terrestrial patterns, attractors, and even nymphs suddenly lost much of their effectiveness. The trout had become overwhelmingly focused on a single food source.

Matching the baitfish was no longer simply another option. It became essential.

That did not mean we abandoned every other fly pattern.

Experienced guides knew the minnow season was approaching, but no one could predict the exact day it would begin. Each morning, we carried the full range of flies normally used on the Collón Curá—hopper patterns, attractors, dry flies, nymphs, and streamers—ready for whatever conditions the river presented.

Then the river made the decision for us.

The first clouds of puyén would appear, slowly moving upstream from the reservoir. Around our drift boats they surrounded us by the thousands, carpeting the riverbanks as they swam steadily against the current. Brown and rainbow trout immediately changed their feeding behavior.

From that moment on, there was little room for doubt.

Once the migration was underway, sinking lines and minnow imitations became the natural choice. Zonker and  Matuka streamers tied to imitate the size, profile, and movement of puyén became our most productive patterns.

From Explosion to Established Pattern

During the first years after 1993, the phenomenon was even more dramatic than it is today. So many trout concentrated in the lower reaches of the Collón Curá that stretches of the upper river, normally full of fish, often seemed strangely quiet while the puyén migration was underway.

Around our boats, dozens of trout could often be seen feeding at the same time. They chased baitfish across entire pools, pinned them against the banks, and attacked with astonishing aggression. It remains one of the most spectacular feeding events I have ever witnessed in freshwater fly fishing.

Over the years, the explosive nature of those first seasons gradually moderated. The immense concentrations of puyén became less dramatic, and trout spread more evenly throughout the river system.

The migration, however, never disappeared. Today, every guide on the Collón Curá
recognizes the signs.

By mid- to late February, we know the season is approaching, but the river still decides when it begins. Then, almost without warning, the first schools of puyén appear, trout abruptly change their feeding behavior, and every guide knows exactly what to do.

What Remains

More than three decades have passed since those first extraordinary seasons. The Collón Curá we knew before 1993 is gone forever, along with dozens of miles of remarkable trout water that disappeared beneath the reservoir.

Those waters can never be replaced.

Yet the free-flowing section that remained developed a unique seasonal character unlike anything we had experienced before. Every year, the arrival of the puyén transforms the river again, creating one of Patagonia’s most distinctive late-season trout fisheries.

Most visiting anglers simply know it as the minnow season.

Those of us who witnessed its beginning remember something different: a river changing before our eyes; trout suddenly behaving in ways we had never seen before; and, gradually, the realization that those memorable fish were not the story.

They were simply the evidence that something much bigger had taken place beneath the
surface.

That was the beginning of what I still call the Minnow Revolution.

— Jorge Trucco
Founder, Patagonia Outfitters